ARC has produced at least 1 major musical production per year since it was formed in 1996. Occaisonally smaller musicals and plays have been staged in the “off season”
- 1996 – The Mikado
- 1997 – How To Succeed In Business Without Really Trying
- 1998 – Anything Goes
- 1998 – Late Nights in the Moonlight Motel*
- 1999 – Into The Woods
- 1999 – Blackrock
- 2000 – Guys & Dolls
- 2001 – Sugar
- 2002 – The Last Supper*
- 2002 – Fiddler on the Roof
- 2003 – Kiss Me, Kate
- 2004 – Sweet Charity
- 2005 – Witches of Eastwick
- 2006 – Hot Mikado
- 2007 – Cabaret
- 2008 – Godspell
- 2009 – West Side Story
- 2010 – Hello, Dolly!
- 2011 – Grease
- 2012 – The Breakfast Club
- 2012 – Jekyl and Hyde
- 2013 – The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee
- 2013 – Singin’ In the Rain
- 2014 – All Shook Up
* denotes a play.